Custom Search
 



 
 
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?

The 3G cellular portion of India’s telecom spectrum auctions have just concluded—raking in over  Rs 67,000 crores ( Rs 677 billion or $ 1.5 billion) for the exchequer—almost twice what was expected. But by scooping in all the money right away, is government killing the goose that laid the golden egg, asks PRASHANTO K. ROY, Chief Editor, Cybermedia group of publications:
The figures are staggering. It may look like a stroke of genius by the government, and may be poised to wipe out a tenth of our fiscal deficit, but that is a short-sighted view. Operators are going to be hard pressed to recover the money, while keeping voice and data services affordable.

Affordable mobile data services and high quality mobile voice would have given a big boost to industry and the economy, employment, tax collections. The finance ministry has taken the easier way out--taking all the money upfront. This is not unlike what hotels in India did by overpricing phone calls (and later wi-fi), forcing customers to use alternatives. A simpler parable is of the goose that laid the golden eggs.

I am not suggesting that the operators will collapse and die under the strain: they are innovative, and will find ways to thrive just as they managed to remain profitable in the world's lowest ARPU regime while facing unique cost pressures like diesel genset backup for thousands of mobile towers. But it will not be easy. Other than the nearly Rs. 70,000 crore spectrum license fees, the leading telcos have to worry about the premium they will now pay for the 2G spectrum they own in excess of 6.25 MHz. The pressure to recover the investment will be very high. If it could be recovered from the entire mobile base, it would be easier, but nine-tenths of that base is low-ARPU prepaid customers. Taking the postpaid base, the telcos have to somehow recover over Rs 10,000 per customer for just the license fees.

What we would see, therefore, is high initial pricing of 3G data services. That would be India's second 3G market fiasco, the first being when the BSNL-MTNL duo were allowed to launch 3G services a year ahead of the rest, and failed to get any traction. I sincerely hope this does not happen, and that the operators are able to come up with innovative ways to launch affordable data services--and raise the quality of voice service, while keeping it affordable.

May 22 2010




    


Post Your Comments Now
       
  Name  
  Email  
  Comment  
     
     
       
       
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Satch on July  10,  2011
  "I'm ipmerssed! You've managed the almost impossible."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Satch on July  10,  2011
  "I\'m ipmerssed! You\'ve managed the almost impossible."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Microsoft OEM Software on March  08,  2012
  "SX5hXa Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog post.Really looking forward to read more."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Microsoft OEM Software on March  08,  2012
  "SX5hXa Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog post.Really looking forward to read more."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by wholesale men clothing on March  21,  2012
  "A big thank you for your blog post."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by wholesale men clothing on March  21,  2012
  "A big thank you for your blog post."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Bristol Airport Hotels on April  19,  2012
  "szMa1s This is one awesome article post.Thanks Again. Really Cool."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Bristol Airport Hotels on April  19,  2012
  "szMa1s This is one awesome article post.Thanks Again. Really Cool."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Bristol Airport Hotels on April  19,  2012
  "qtaAmV Very informative article post.Thanks Again. Really Cool."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Bristol Airport Hotels on April  19,  2012
  "qtaAmV Very informative article post.Thanks Again. Really Cool."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Yadi on   30,  2012
  "Just about all I can state is, I'm not sure what to say! Except naturally, for the wnuedrfol tips which are shared within this blog. I am able to think of a zillion fun strategies to read the content on this site. I do believe I will finally take action using your tips on those things I could not have been able to address alone. You were so innovative to allow me to be one of those to profit from your useful information. Please realize how much I appreciate it."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Yadi on   30,  2012
  "Just about all I can state is, I''m not sure what to say! Except naturally, for the wnuedrfol tips which are shared within this blog. I am able to think of a zillion fun strategies to read the content on this site. I do believe I will finally take action using your tips on those things I could not have been able to address alone. You were so innovative to allow me to be one of those to profit from your useful information. Please realize how much I appreciate it."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by cheap seo services on   20,  2012
  "rUgBWQ I really enjoy the blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by cheap seo services on   20,  2012
  "rUgBWQ I really enjoy the blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by cheap seo services on   21,  2012
  "1qbyCH I value the article.Much thanks again."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by cheap seo services on   21,  2012
  "1qbyCH I value the article.Much thanks again."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by cheap seo services on October  19,  2012
  "Zm6gUh Fantastic article post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by cheap seo services on October  19,  2012
  "Zm6gUh Fantastic article post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by Diormouro on November  08,  2012
  " Cell applications have grown the need of your working day. They allow you to create the most beneficial of your respective cellphones. Enabling you to be extra effective at perform or to acquire additional exciting; there are actually numerous applications you can choose between. Even so, it is engaging to know that inspite of countless programs available in Google Android Current market plus the apple iphone Retail store, persons are however trying to find much more apps. They need new apps in accordance to their need to have and liking. online mobile app developers firms may help individuals customise cell apps according to their personalized need and desire. There are a selection of organizations offering cell applications, but you will have to only accept the top one. Before you decide to accept a firm, you should require under consideration quite a few points so that you can choose the ideal organization. First of all, it's essential to be sure you discover out how expert a business is. The more professional a business, the higher it may serve you. In addition, you should obtain out the sort of apps an organization can offer you. Also, don't forget to discover out simply how much an app will run you. It is also critical to search out out the general track record of the provider making sure that you might know when you are employing the appropriate one particular. It'll also assist you continue being secure from frauds. Talking for the experts in a firm can help. You can fulfill diverse companies and find out whenever they realize your need and the things they can do in your case. After you shortlist some firms, evaluate among their presents. The company which can present you with all the most effective app for the need to have at affordable price is often the ideal a single. Before you decide to request to rent a cell app organization it's essential to also ascertain your very own have to have. The clearer you're about whatever you want the greater it can be. That's why it's important to take some time and evaluate what type of an app you have to have. The easiest way to rent a cellular application organization is usually to look for them online. There are actually several corporations that provide on the web services, assisting you will get the sort of application you need through the convenience of your residence. It is possible to conveniently contact these companies, skim by means of their profile or speak to their industry experts to grasp what they can perform for you. So wait no much more, and get on line to hire the top mobile app organization now! "
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by link building on October  23,  2013
  "rQCkfC Great article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by link building on October  23,  2013
  "rQCkfC Great article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by crorkz mattz on January  16,  2015
  "h4imxF Thank you for another excellent article. Where else could anybody get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such info."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by crorkz mattz on January  16,  2015
  "h4imxF Thank you for another excellent article. Where else could anybody get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such info."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by crork backlinks on   03,  2015
  "Zvdrn5 What a funny blog! I actually loved watching this humorous video with my relatives as well as with my colleagues."
     
Indian 3G spectrum auction: milestone or millstone?
by crork backlinks on   03,  2015
  "Zvdrn5 What a funny blog! I actually loved watching this humorous video with my relatives as well as with my colleagues."